General Dentistry

Canker sores vs cold sores: how to tell them apart

Canker sores form inside the mouth and are not contagious. Cold sores appear on or around the lips, are caused by a virus and spread easily. How to tell them apart, what helps, and when to get one checked.

By Marina DentistryJuly 28, 20268 min read

Canker sores form inside the mouth, on the inner cheeks, inner lips, tongue or gums, and they are not contagious. Cold sores usually appear on or around the lips, are caused by the herpes simplex virus, and can spread to other people from the first tingle until they heal. Both kinds usually heal on their own in one to two weeks, and a sore of any kind that has not healed in about two weeks is worth having checked by a dentist or doctor.

Below is how to tell them apart, what tends to set each one off, what helps while they heal, and the signs that mean a sore should be looked at.

The quick way to tell them apart

Location is the most useful clue.

  • Inside the mouth, on soft, movable tissue: most likely a canker sore. It is a single shallow ulcer or a small cluster, round or oval, with a white or yellowish center and a red border.
  • On the lip, the edge of the lip or the skin around the mouth: most likely a cold sore. It starts as tingling or burning, turns into a group of small fluid-filled blisters, then breaks open and crusts over.
  • Contagious or not: canker sores cannot be passed to anyone else. Cold sores can, through kissing, shared cups, utensils and lip balm, and by touching the sore.

There are exceptions. A first cold sore infection, often in childhood, can cause sores inside the mouth as well as on the lips, and some people with weakened immune systems get them inside the mouth later too. If you cannot tell which you have, a quick look from your dentist usually settles it.

What a canker sore is

A canker sore, which dentists call an aphthous ulcer, is a small open sore in the lining of the mouth. According to Cleveland Clinic, canker sores usually appear at the base of the gums, on or under the tongue, or inside the lips or cheeks, and they are not contagious.

They sting more than their size suggests, especially with salty, spicy or acidic food like citrus, tomato and vinegar. Talking and brushing can hurt for the first few days. Most are small and heal without a scar. Larger canker sores are less common, take longer to heal, and are more likely to need a prescription to settle.

Nobody knows exactly what causes canker sores, and they tend to run in families. They are not caused by poor hygiene, and having them does not mean anything is wrong with your teeth.

What a cold sore is

A cold sore, sometimes called a fever blister, is a flare of the herpes simplex virus, usually the type known as HSV-1. Once someone has the virus, it stays in the body and can flare again from time to time, often in the same spot.

Cleveland Clinic describes three stages: a tingling, itching or numb feeling where the sore will form, then fluid-filled blisters, then oozing and a crust as the sore heals. Cold sores usually last one to two weeks, and the same Cleveland Clinic page notes they are most infectious within 24 hours of first forming.

Many adults carry the virus without knowing it, and catching it does not reflect anything about your hygiene or habits. It is simply very easy to pass along.

Common triggers

Canker sores

  • A small injury inside the mouth: biting your cheek, brushing too hard, a jagged edge on a chipped tooth or filling, or a braces bracket rubbing the lip
  • Stress or poor sleep
  • Certain foods: acidic or spicy foods bother some people, and the triggers vary from person to person
  • Hormone changes, such as around a menstrual period
  • Toothpaste ingredients: Cleveland Clinic lists toothpastes containing sodium lauryl sulfate among possible triggers
  • Nutritional gaps or health conditions: low levels of some vitamins or minerals and certain digestive or immune conditions can play a role, which is why frequent sores are worth mentioning to your doctor

Cold sores

Cleveland Clinic lists illness, stress, sun exposure, injury to the mouth and hormonal changes as common triggers. On the Westside, sun is the one most people can do something about: a lip balm with SPF on beach days, boat days and long runs on the bike path can help people who flare after a lot of sun. Our summer smile guide has more on protecting your mouth outdoors.

What helps a canker sore heal

Most canker sores settle on their own. The aim is to keep them comfortable and avoid irritating them while they do.

  • Rinse with warm salt water a few times a day, letting it fall out rather than spitting hard.
  • Skip the irritants for a few days: citrus, tomato, chips, spicy food and very hot drinks.
  • Use an over-the-counter numbing gel or protective paste from a pharmacy, following the label.
  • Brush gently with a soft brush, and try a toothpaste without sodium lauryl sulfate if you get sores often.
  • Cover rubbing edges. Orthodontic wax over a bracket or wire can stop a sore from being reopened every time you talk.

If a broken tooth, rough filling or sharp edge keeps causing sores in the same spot, your dentist can smooth or repair it. For large, frequent or slow sores, your dentist or doctor may prescribe a rinse or ointment that helps them heal.

What helps a cold sore heal

  • Start treatment early. Antiviral medicines can shorten an outbreak, and Cleveland Clinic notes they work well when started early, ideally within 48 hours. If you get cold sores often, ask your doctor or pharmacist about having a plan ready for the first tingle.
  • Leave it alone. Picking or squeezing a blister can spread the virus and slow healing.
  • Wash your hands after touching the area or applying cream.
  • Do not share cups, utensils, towels, razors or lip products until the sore has fully healed.
  • Avoid kissing babies, anyone pregnant, and anyone with a weakened immune system while a sore is active.

If you have a cleaning or dental visit during an outbreak, call the office ahead of time. Stretching the lips during a routine visit can reopen the sore, so a cleaning may be easier a week or two later, while urgent care for a toothache still goes ahead.

Sores that are neither

Not every mouth sore is a canker sore or a cold sore. Others your dentist sees often include:

  • Rubbing sores from a denture, retainer or braces
  • Burns from hot pizza or coffee, usually on the roof of the mouth
  • White patches that wipe off and leave a red area, which can be a yeast infection called thrush
  • Clusters of small sores in young children, sometimes with a fever and spots on the hands and feet, which can be a viral illness to raise with your pediatrician

Some of these clear up on their own once the cause is removed, and others need treatment. Our family dentistry page explains how we see children and adults in the same practice.

When a sore needs to be checked

Most mouth sores are harmless and heal on schedule. Have a sore looked at if:

  • It has not healed in about two weeks. Cleveland Clinic advises calling your provider about canker sores that last longer than two weeks, and about cold sores that have not improved after about 10 days.
  • Sores keep coming back, several times a year.
  • It is very large or so painful you cannot eat or drink normally.
  • It comes with a fever or you feel unwell.
  • It does not hurt but will not go away, or you notice a red or white patch, a lump or a thick area that stays.

The two-week mark matters because a sore that does not heal is one of the things dentists look at closely during an oral cancer screening, which is part of a routine exam. Most often the cause turns out to be something simple, and checking is how that gets confirmed. Our general dentistry page covers what a routine exam includes.

Call the office for anything urgent, such as a sore with spreading swelling in the gum or face. Swelling that affects your breathing or swallowing needs an emergency room right away.

What a visit at Marina Dentistry involves

If you come in about a mouth sore, your dentist looks at the sore and the tissue around it, asks how long it has been there and whether it has happened before, checks for sharp teeth or appliances that could be causing it, and takes X-rays only if something points to a tooth problem. If treatment is needed, you receive a written plan with pricing before anything is done, and if a sore needs a closer look elsewhere, your dentist explains why and where. Marina Dentistry is at 4292 Lincoln Blvd in Marina del Rey, open six days a week, including Saturday from 8 AM to 4 PM, at (310) 578-5000. The office accepts all PPO plans and a range of HMO plans including Delta Dental and Anthem; confirm your plan with the office. You can book online or read the new patient information before your visit.

This article is general information from Marina Dentistry and not a diagnosis. Only an exam can tell you what is right for your mouth. Request an appointment or call (310) 578-5000.

FAQ

Questions this article answers

Is a canker sore the same as a cold sore?

No. A canker sore is a shallow ulcer inside the mouth that is not contagious. A cold sore is caused by the herpes simplex virus, usually appears on or around the lips as a cluster of small blisters, and spreads easily to other people. Both usually heal within one to two weeks.

Are canker sores contagious?

No. Canker sores cannot be passed to anyone through kissing, sharing drinks or any other contact. They are linked to things like small mouth injuries, stress, certain foods and some health conditions, not to a virus you can catch. Cold sores are different and do spread, which is why telling the two apart matters.

How long does a canker sore last?

Most canker sores heal on their own in one to two weeks, and the soreness usually eases after the first few days. Larger sores can take longer. If a sore has not healed in about two weeks, keeps coming back several times a year, or makes eating difficult, have your dentist or doctor take a look.

When is a cold sore contagious?

A cold sore can spread from the first tingling stage until it has fully healed, and it is most contagious in the first day or so after blisters form. Avoid kissing, sharing cups, utensils or lip balm, and touching the sore during that time, and wash your hands after applying any cream.

Should I see a dentist for a mouth sore?

See a dentist or doctor if a sore has not healed in about two weeks, keeps returning, is very large or painful, or comes with a fever. A sore that does not hurt but will not go away is worth checking too. Most turn out to be harmless, and an exam is how that gets confirmed.

Ready when you are

Request a time online and we will confirm by phone or text during office hours. Same-day visits for dental emergencies.